Sunday, May 27, 2012

Fast Estimation


Imagine you have just completed some Product Discovery work and have a pile of User Stories that need to be estimated. You look at the pile and think, wow that will take hours to estimate using Planning Poker. I just want rough estimates so that we can put together a release plan. We know the plan will change in the future, but we need some starting point. What can I do? 

The answer is Fast Estimation. 

Fast Estimation is derived from Planning Poker. With some preparation and a 1 hour workshop it is common for a team to estimate about 30 User Stories. Teams I have worked with have successfully used it to estimate new functionality, automation of processes, improvements to internal practices and organisational change work.

While estimation is the main objective of the Fast Estimation process, another significant benefit you get for free is Shared Understanding. By this I mean the discussions that occur help to clarify in the minds of the team members what work is required, how it inter-relates and how big the entire backlog is. The knowledge that is gained about the backlog as a whole can often be more valuable then the estimates assigned to individual User Stories.

Fast Estimation Process

Preparation
Write out the User Stories to be estimated onto Index Cards of the same colour. A short cut that often works well is to just write the Title of the User Story on the index card and have the details of the User Story on hand during the session (i.e. in an electronic tool, or a printed spreadsheet, etc).

Find one to five Reference User Stories. These are User Stories that are well understood by the team and will act as a reference point for the upcoming comparative estimation. Ideally the team will have recently completed those User Stories or have at least estimated them in Story Points. The Reference User Stories should have differing Story Points, ideally being in the 2 to 20 range. I recommend at least three reference User Stories and usually aim for five, however you can get away with one. The case where your team is new and does not have any reference User Stories; sounds like a topic for another day. If you are really stuck just pick a User Story that you think is 3 Story Points, and use that for your Reference User Story.


Write out the Reference User Stories onto Index Cards of a different colour to the cards used for the User Stories to be estimated.


Schedule a 1 hour meeting in a room that has a long table, big enough for the team to gather around.


During the workshop
Set the scene for the workshop by explaining the following points

  • The objective of the workshop is to roughly estimate this stack of User Stories (show them the stack of Index Cards so that they can see how many there are), this will help to emphasise that time is of the essence. 
  • Fast Estimation will only rough estimates for these User Stories. 
  • There will be lots of assumptions and hence the estimates will not be very accurate.
  • The team will get another chance to re-estimate these User Stories in normal grooming session prior to starting work on the User Stories.

Layout one set up Planning Poker cards on a long conference table in ascending order i.e. 0, 0.5 .. 110, ∞.  It is a good idea to leave more space between the lower / middle numbers as hopefully more of the User Stories will end up there. If there are lots of User Stories at the large end of the scale that is a whole different problem, good luck with that ;).

Place the Reference User Stories below the Planning Poker card that corresponds to its Story Points. As per the picture below.


Fast Estimation reference user stories placed, ready to start


Picture 1: Planning Poker cards and Reference User Stories, with un-estimated User Stories at the bottom.

Confirm with the participants that they understand the Reference User Stories and agree with the Story Points for each. You may need to adjust one or more of these. Once you progress past this point, do not change the Reference User Story – Story Points any more these are now set in stone.

Divide up the User Stories roughly and hand them out to the participants.

Give the participants a couple of minutes to quickly read their set of User Stories to themselves.

Pick someone at random and ask them to read out their User Story and then place it underneath the Planning Poker card that corresponds to their estimate. Only allow a brief time for this. Ask the group if they are happy with that estimate and discuss/move it as necessary. Encourage participants to move the card if they disagree and to explain their justification at the same time.

Fast Estimation first user story placed


Picture 2: First User Story Estimated

Ask the group if there are any similar User Stories in peoples stacks. If so, repeat step 8 for those User Stories. Once there are no more similar User Stories pick another person at random and repeat step 8 for that User Story.

Work your wait through all of the User Stories, placing and discussing, finding similar User Stories, etc. etc.

Once all of the cards are all in position you can quickly write the Story Point estimate on each Index Card and gather them up.
Fast Estimation all stories estimated




Picture 3: All User Stories estimated 

As a final wrap up to the meeting it is again worth mentioning that the team may need to re-estimate these User Stories using Planning Poker before taking them into a sprint planning meeting.

A variation I have tried that did not work as well
After handing out the index cards, everyone places their cards at once in a big rush of activity. Then the team discusses them and re-estimates them as appropriate. This approach raises the energy in the room but it is a bit more confusing. Individuals will find it confusing to place their cards without the understanding of the backlog that they build up while discussing the User Stories one by one. The benefit to this approach is that very rough estimates are assigned to all of the User Stories up front, so if you run out of time at least you have everything estimated.

Teaching Fast Estimation
I have an example game to teach people Fast Estimation which extends on the fruit estimation of Planning Poker that I learnt in the Certified Scrum Master course taught by Rowan Bunning.

Write out the following Items To Cook on Index Cards, and place ‘B.L.T’ your three Story Point Reference User Story  (I have found that due to the simplicity of these User Stories 1 reference story is enough). 

Ask the participant to estimate cooking these items from scratch. I.e. for Eggs Benedict they are expected to make their own hollandaise sauce. Guide them through the Fast Estimation process,  this game usually takes less then 10 minutes (provided the participants are familiar with Planning Poker and Story Points).

Items to Cook


  • Eggs Benedict
  • Tin Baked Beans
  • Fruit Salad
  • B.L.T.
  • Crispy skinned Salmon
  • Poached Eggs SoufflĂ©
  • Cheese Burger
  • 64 Cup Cakes
  • Garden Salad
  • Alacarte, 3 courses for two
  • Cheese Cake
  • Duck Ala orange
  • Caesar Salad
  • Alacarte, 3 courses for ten
  • Lasagne
  • Pineapple upside down cake
  • Burrito’s
  • Mashed Potato
  • Beef Korma
  • Banoffee Pie
  • Fish & Chips
  • 12 Fancy cup cakes


Interested in estimation?





Related Reading
I can recommend these blogs for other great approaches to estimating stacks of User Stories:


Good luck and have fun with it

I hope that this approach helps you and your team to get a great start with your next project. I would appreciate any feedback that you have, especially on applying this for your team.

Tuesday, May 8, 2012

Book Review: Presentation Zen - Simple Ideas on Presentation Design and Delivery, by Garr Reynolds



Visually it is a beautiful book that shows off Garr Reynolds design skills.

If you like discussing design and the art behind it, then this book is for you. It does a good job of discussing the design of presentations from an abstract approach, the writing style of his blog Presentation Zen shines through.

However if you want to improve your presentations this book offers very little. The useful information in the book could be condensed to about 20 pages; you may be better off searching the web for articles on basic design principles.

I picked it up hoping to improve my presentations, I walk away knowing about a few more free picture sites, having seen some great examples of slides and learn a few tips. Unfortunately the Zen of presentation design has not passed into my way thinking.

2 stars